Don't let loggers rip you off

Selling 24 acres of timber in Frazeysburg, Ohio

How we got this landowner $24,994 for her timber sale in Muskingum County

Calling in a consulting forester and setting clear objectives for a timber sale

In late Spring of 2025, a young woman who resides in Florida inherited a 24-acre parcel of land near Frazeysburg, Ohio. Her father contacted us on her behalf for a consultation on a potential sale of some timber from the property.  

Their main objectives were to: 

Harvest and sell enough timber to meet some upcoming expenses for her;

Develop a timber stand improvement (TSI) plan to increase its future harvest potential;

Get help with wildlife habitat design to attract deer & game birds to the land.

Initial results of the consultation

When we cruised the property we found plenty of timber growing on it to meet their current income objective. We prescribed a limited, selective harvest – in one section of the stand with plenty of mature trees. 

Furthermore, doing the cut the way we recommended in this central area will open up wide areas in the forest canopy that will cause new tree saplings and native grasses to regenerate and take hold rapidly – making both great browsing fodder for whitetail deer and good cover for ground-nesting game birds, like ruffed grouse.

Note that we selected to cut fewer than ten trees per acre, and about half of all the timber on the property is outside the boundary for this low-impact harvest. That acreage is  reserved to grow and continue maturing for a later harvest.

The owner and her father approved the plan and retained us to do the work to sell the timber for them. The harvest plan is shown on these maps. Click either map to enlarge it.

The aerial map shows a yellow line marking the property’s boundary. The red line shows the boundary enclosing the area of the harvest. The blue line shows where we want the skidding road to be built. The blue circle marks the parking area for logging equipment. The purple triangle marks the log landing or staging area.   

The topographical map shows the same markings on the parcel, but also its underlying terrain. This allows the loggers we invited to bid on the timber to ascertain the difficulty of the harvest in advance, which in this case is low. 

Selecting timber to sell for the owner

We marked 202 mature trees for harvest this time, with a final tally of 55,007 board feet, measured on the Doyle Scale and in Form Class 78. This table shows the full inventory of each to be harvested, classified by species.  

We prepared a Notice of Standing Timber Sale and sent it (with a full bid prospectus including all you see on this page) to 20 master loggers and sawmills who we know do good work, making minimal impact impact on forest floors, and do proper restoration.

Species Trees Total BFV % of BFV Avg DBH
Beech
3
645
1.5
22
Aspen
2
450
<1
20
Black cherry
2
459
<1
21
Black oak
6
2,210
4
23
Black walnut
8
1,842
3.3
19.7
Hickory
6
1,868
3.3
21.7
Hard maple
44
10,739
19.5
20.7
Red oak
4
2,164
3.9
26
Soft maple
6
1,346
2.4
26
Scarlet oak
1
376
<1
30
Sycamore
4
1,317
2.3
22.5
White oak
4
787
1.4
19.5
Yellow poplar
112
30,604
55.6
20.3
TOTAL
202
55,007
100
20.7

Getting competitive bids for the timber

All the loggers received notice of the sale on August 8, 2025 and were given 19 days to visit the property and satisfy themselves about the quantity, quality and accessibility of the timber offered for sale. 

Sealed bids were due at our offices by noon on Wednesday, August 27, and we received five bids in these amounts:

Top bid: $24,944 
Next bid: $23,526 
Next bid: $22,093  
Next bid: $21, 500
Next bid: $18,888

The seller has accepted the highest bid and the logger has been notified that the contract (which we have already prepared) will be awarded to his firm. 

Bid amount $ per board foot
$24,944
.453
$23,526
.427
$22,093
.401
$21,500
.390
$18,888
.343

The inventory in this sale was about 55% yellow poplar, and we sold it to salvage its timber value due to the mass mortality event affecting poplar trees in southeast Ohio here. 

What happens after the sale

The winning bidder has 10 days from August 27 to sign the sale contract, and to pay the owner a non-refundable 35% deposit ($8748) of the full sales price.

He will then be afforded sufficient time to schedule the work to be done. But he must pay the final 65% balance ($16,196) in full to the owner before he is allowed onto the land again to begin the harvest.

The contract has enforcement provisions to ensure that only the 202 trees we marked will be taken, and that the logger adheres to Ohio’s BMP Guidelines for erosion control and seeding of disturbed areas. And we will take and hold a performance bond of $10,000 and not release it until we are satisfied that restoration has been done correctly.

We will also file a Foresty Pollution Prevention Plan with the Muskingum Soil and Water Conservation District so that they can inspect the logger’s work too.

When and how the timber harvest will proceed

The harvest on this property will begin in mid-September and finish in about a week. We will oversee every aspect of the harvest, making multiple unannounced visits to inspect the site and ensure that the work is done correctly.

Throughout the harvest process, we will keep her apprised of its progress with video and photo documentation. She doesn’t have to take time away from work to travel to Ohio for anything.  

Once harvest is completed our foresters will write a Woodland Stewardship Management Plan for the property. Once approved by the state forester for an official forest land designation, the property will be qualified to enter Ohio’s CAUV Program for timber production and the owner will enjoy a 50% reduction in property tax while growing more timber for harvest later.  

We will also show the owner how to qualify her property for the Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP) which offers financial and technical assistance to improve the wildlife habitat on her land.

Key takeaways from this timber sale